“Demarchi”: The Rise of Oligarchic Influence in American Democracy, are we watching?
Executive Summary
This white paper examines the interplay of democracy and oligarchy in the United States, a phenomenon we term "Demarchi." The term reflects the increasing influence of wealthy elites, or oligarchs, in shaping U.S. politics through mechanisms like campaign donations, super PACs, and dark money organizations. This influence has been amplified by the 2010 Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, which eliminated restrictions on independent political expenditures by corporations, unions, and other entities.
The implications of Citizens United are far-reaching, transforming political campaigns into financial arms races where wealth often determines political success. This document provides a historical and analytical exploration of this trend, outlining how the U.S. has become a hybrid of democracy and oligarchy. It also compares the U.S. system to more transparent political financing models like Australia's and concludes with actionable solutions to restore equity and trust in the democratic process.
1. The Landmark Decision: Citizens United and the Floodgates of Dark Money
The 2010 Supreme Court decision Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission fundamentally altered the landscape of U.S. campaign finance. By equating political expenditures with free speech under the First Amendment, the Court opened the door for unlimited spending by corporations, unions, and other entities, provided the funds are not directly coordinated with candidates.
This ruling triggered a dramatic increase in "dark money" spending—funds routed through organizations that do not disclose their donors. The decision effectively dismantled existing campaign finance laws, creating a system where wealth equates to political influence. Critics argue this has eroded democratic principles by amplifying the voices of the wealthy while marginalizing ordinary citizens.
2. Defining the Oligarch: Wealth, Power, and Influence
An oligarch is traditionally defined as an individual with significant wealth and political influence. In the U.S., oligarchs often belong to the top 0.1% of income earners, controlling vast resources and using their wealth to shape public policy. Unlike the broader "1%" often referenced in political discourse, oligarchs operate in a financial stratosphere far removed from the average citizen.
Prominent examples include Elon Musk and Bill Gates, whose wealth allows them to influence policy debates, fund political campaigns, and drive public narratives. This elite class wields disproportionate power in shaping laws and regulations that align with their interests, often at the expense of broader societal equity.
3. The Role of Super PACs and Dark Money Organizations
Super PACs, or independent expenditure-only committees, are a direct result of Citizens United. These entities can raise and spend unlimited funds to support or oppose political candidates, provided they do not coordinate directly with campaigns. Super PACs have become central to U.S. elections, allowing wealthy donors to exert influence without significant transparency.
Dark money organizations, such as 501(c)(4) nonprofits, complicate the issue further by shielding donor identities. These groups can fund political advertisements, grassroots outreach, and other campaign activities while keeping their contributors anonymous. Case studies, such as Future Forward and America PAC, illustrate the vast sums of money involved—$900 million in the 2024 Harris campaign alone.
This article is for subscribers, to continue reading and stay informed sub